© Getty Images

The map -

In 2006, a Chinese lawyer and collector named Liu Gang unveiled an old map at a Shanghai bookshop. The map was supposedly an 18th-century copy of a map from 1418.

© Getty Images

What’s so special about the map? -

Unlike other European maps back then, this one depicted North and South America, as well as Australia and Antarctica.

© Getty Images

Who created this map? -

The man behind the map was supposedly Chinese explorer Zheng He (1371-1433). The Chinese Muslim eunuch traveled across the seas for 30 years.

© Getty Images

An experienced navigator -

From 1405 to 1433, Zheng He is said to have set sail on seven voyages through the Pacific and Indian Oceans.

© Getty Images

Historical evidence -

Indeed, there are historical records of his trips to Southeast Asia, India, the Persian Gulf, and the east coast of Africa, as well as evidence of his using advanced navigational techniques and ships.

© Getty Images

Bold claims -

But according to former British submarine lieutenant-commander and author Gavin Menzies, Zheng He went even further, and was the first one to discover America.

© Getty Images

The Chinese were the first -

According to Menzies, the Chinese explorer did so in 1421—that’s 71 years before Columbus!

© Getty Images

Theory -

Menzies laid out his theory in his 2003 book, entitled ‘1421: The Year China Discovered America.’

© Getty Images

Contradiction -

Menzies has welcomed the map as evidence, despite the fact that the map of America is dated three years (1418) prior to when Zheng He supposedly discovered the New World (1421).

© Getty Images

Authenticity -

It goes without saying that the authenticity of the map has been disputed.

© Getty Images

Anachronisms -

For instance, Gong Yingyan, a historian at Zhejiang University, claims that the map has too many anachronisms to date from the 15th century.

© Getty Images

Globe -

Yingyan also argues that Chinese cartographers didn’t use the style of projection seen (three-dimensional globe) on a flat sheet. This technique was introduced later by the Europeans.

© Getty Images

Notes -

The map has notes about the religious and cultural features of peoples in the continents, but it contains vocabulary that would have not been used in the early 15th century.

© Getty Images

The term for God -

An example includes the word used to describe the Western God, which wasn’t used until after the Jesuits arrived in China much later, in the 16th century.

© Getty Images

Hoax -

"I had high hopes when I first heard about the existence of such a map, but I can see now that it is an entirely ordinary map that proves nothing," said Gong Yingyan.

© Getty Images

Other opinions -

Historian Geoff Wade was yet another man to find numerous issues with the map that defy its authenticity, one being the fact that it’s a dual-hemisphere map, which is an exclusively European cartographic tradition.

© Getty Images

Big continent -

Plus, North and South America are represented as massive continents, which is something a mariner wouldn’t have known back then.

© Getty Images

Copied mistake -

Another one is the fact that California is depicted as an island. This was a common “mistake” in European maps of the 17th century.

© Getty Images

Name -

Zheng He is referred to as Ma San-bao. This would never happen, simply because of the fact that the emperor had given him the surname Zheng, so everyone would call him that. Always.

© Getty Images

Too many details -

The details of rivers, mountains, and other non-coastal elements are just way too accurate. These are more akin to European cartography, rather than Chinese.

© Getty Images

The Himalayas -

The iconic mountain range is marked as the world’s highest: a fact that wasn’t discovered until the 19th century.

© Getty Images

Others came before Zheng He -

Zheng He is not the first man to be pointed out as the one who first discovered America, and probably won’t be the last. In fact, there are several theories that claim that many reached the New World before Columbus.

© Getty Images

The Vikings -

One theory says that in 1000 CE, Viking explorer Leif Erikson sailed to a land he named "Vinland," which was the Canadian province of Newfoundland.

© Getty Images

The Vikings -

Indeed, a Norse settlement dating back to circa 1021 was unearthed at L'Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland in the 1960s. This remains the most compelling archaeological evidence of Viking presence in the New World.

© Getty Images

Irish monks -

According to folklore, Saint Brendan and a group of monks sailed from Ireland to North America sometime in the 6th century.

© Getty Images

Prince Madoc ab Owain Gwynedd -

Legend has it that Welsh prince Madoc  sailed to America in 1170, where he settled.

© Public Domain

Portuguese explorers -

Portuguese explorers João Fernandes Lavrador and Pêro de Barcelos are also believed to have reached the shores of Labrador in North America before Columbus.

© Getty Images

The case for Pacific Islanders -

Unlike the bogus Zheng He theory, Pacific Islanders may have actually reached South America before Columbus.

© Getty Images

The case for Pacific Islanders -

At least there is actual genetic information that links Polynesian DNA to an indigenous Brazilian tribe called the Botocudos.

Sources: (The New York Times) (The Guardian) (NPR) (Gizmodo) (ARS Technica) (The Economist)

See also: Expeditions that changed the course of history

© Getty Images