© Getty Images

Hurricane Katrina - Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans in 2005, destroying homes and critical infrastructure, displacing over one million people, and causing the tragic death of 1,833 lives.

© Getty Images

FEMA -

Beyond the devastation to people's lives, it also revealed the Federal Emergency Management Agency's (FEMA) lack of preparation for such disasters.

© Public Domain

New Orleans underwater - Although New Orleans was not directly hit by the storm, the levees and flood walls that sought to protect the city from flooding failed, leaving 80% of the city underwater.

© Getty Images

Infrastructural damage - Over 70% of housing units suffered damage from Hurricane Katrina, requiring mass evacuations. Nearly two decades later, over 75,000 of the city's former residents still have not returned to their homes due to uninhabitable conditions.

© Getty Images

Governmental response -

While Hurricane Katrina was one of the deadliest storms in American history, the government's response (or lack thereof) created additional challenges.

© Getty Images

Missing basic necessities -

Victims of the storm's wrath waited days and weeks for assistance. Many were stuck in shelters without sufficient access to necessities like food, water, or medical care.

© Getty Images

Lack of coordination -

FEMA's operational strategy failed to include coordination with and integration of local authorities, leading to further delays in delivering much-needed aid, leaving tens of thousands struggling for extensive periods of time.

© Getty Images

Aftermath of Hurricane Helene -

Similar problems have surfaced in the aftermath of Hurricane Helene. Despite numerous restructuring efforts, changes in leadership, and improvement initiatives, FEMA’s response continues to fall short in managing crises.

© Getty Images

Intervention obstacles -

Hurricanes such as Sandy, Harvey, and Maria demonstrated that when large-scale emergencies occur, FEMA is unable to provide timely access to aid and remains incapable of overcoming challenges to its intervention strategies.

© Getty Images

Hurricane Helene - Hurricane Helene highlighted many of FEMA's repeated errors. Although Helene was not nearly as destructive as Katrina, it nonetheless caused significant damage along the coast.

© Reuters

Challenges after Helene -

FEMA's response to the necessities emerging from Hurricane Helene remained full of delays and coordination challenges, highlighting its continuous incapacity in effectively planning for and managing large-scale emergencies.

© Getty Images

Bureaucratic processes -

One of the key challenges that FEMA faces is rooted in its bureaucratic processes. Despite efforts to streamline decision-making and approval processes, the agency's lack of proactivity is often due to the challenges regarding the timely release of emergency funds and the delays in accessing and distributing resources.

© Getty Images

Delays to response -

FEMA’s bureaucratic structure requires multiple levels of approval for decisions to be taken, which delays critical response actions.

© Getty Images

Shortages lead to increased needs -

By the time FEMA can mobilize resources, the situation on the ground may have worsened and victims' needs increased.

© Getty Images

Coordination issues -

FEMA continues to lack adequate coordination with local authorities, making the effectiveness of aid distribution a slow process when disasters occur.

© Getty Images

Communities stranded -

Communication and coordination challenges between federal, state, and local agencies often creates confusion regarding response priorities and roles, as well as strategies for accessing and distributing resources. These challenges leave vulnerable communities stranded when they need help the most.

© Getty Images

Budgetary issues -

In 2023, FEMA's annual budget was approximately US$29.5 billion, yet it frequently operates under budget constraints. These constraints affect its capacity to conduct adequate training for its staff and from investing in technology that could improve response efforts.

© Getty Images

Increased rate of disasters - FEMA's budgetary challenges coupled with an increased rate of disasters driven by climate change places further pressure on the agency's ability to respond quickly and effectively to preventing new disasters and providing continuous assistance to ongoing recovery efforts.

© Getty Images

Leadership appointment - FEMA's leadership is determined by each administration, which can change every four years. The high turnover of directors, in conjunction with significant changes in budget and priorities, affects the agency's ability to conduct cohesive long-term planning.

© Getty Images

Lack of staff -

In addition to its high turnover in leadership and budgetary constraints, FEMA often faces staffing shortages. When disaster strikes, the agency relies on temporary employees or contractors, many of whom have limited or no experience or training in dealing with disaster management scenarios and their complexities.

© Getty Images

Increased frequency of crises -

A major challenge that is not exclusive to FEMA's management of crises is the increased frequency of natural disasters overall, such as wildfires, floods, and hurricanes. Budgetary constraints, lack of staff and resources, coupled with increased crises, makes FEMA's already existing weaknesses more evident and impossible to overcome.

© Shutterstock

Mitigating disasters -

Given FEMA’s limitations, one of the additional critiques that it has repeatedly faced is the agency's difficulties in mitigating disasters. While some investments in disaster preparation have increased, FEMA's response is still largely reactive in providing disaster response. This strategy ultimately drags recovery times, rather than preemptively reducing the severity of the necessary response.

© Getty Images

Vulnerable communities -

FEMA has also been heavily criticized for inequitable responses to disasters. Vulnerable communities that live in low-income or rural regions tend to receive slower or reduced assistance, which often furthers already existing inequalities.

© Getty Images

Challenges in accessing aid -

The complexities of digital relief applications also make receiving help difficult for communities facing language barriers or without access to the Internet.

© Getty Images

Allocating supplies -

Supply chains for food, medical supplies, and equipment are often already overwhelmed once disaster strikes. Physically getting needed supplies to an area can be impossible, depending on the infrastructural damage.

© NL Beeld

Transportation challenges -

As budgetary constraints do not allow for FEMA to build large stockpiles of aid in advance, the agency depends on private suppliers. In conjunction with transportation limitations, this can create additional challenges to getting vital supplies to affected areas.

© Getty Images

Pressure on FEMA -

These critiques, while legitimate and well documented, also place immense pressure on FEMA. Public scrutiny is constant and can sometimes cause the agency to take rushed decisions, rather than investing in long-term strategies and planning.

© Getty Images

Public mistrust -

FEMA's failures and reputation have impacted public trust in the agency. Therefore, when evacuation orders are announced or assistance is needed, mistrust and confusion over roles in disaster management make it difficult for communities to be rapidly mobilized.

© Shutterstock

Long-term change -

A clear need for adequate, qualified staffing, consistent long-term planning, meaningful structural change, and access to greater funding underpin the way forward in allowing FEMA to provide the kind of assistance that is needed in a time of increased disaster prevalence.

Sources: (HUD) (Southern Poverty Law Center) (Reuters) (Homeland Security) (GAO) (The New York Times) (International Business Times)

See also: Common myths about climate change

© Getty Images